Thursday, January 22, 2015

Radically Transforming Donor Retention

Last week, I was fortunate enough to spend some time in Texas with an amazing organization. One of the key changes of culture that evolved out of our work together was that the amount of the gift the donor gave was the LEAST important part of their story, that we needed to look at their behavior first.

Here's why: In the latest fundraising effectiveness project report from Bloomerang which you can find here, the numbers are scary:


 

This is NOT sustainable for our industry. Donor retention is more than just a buzzword, it's a lifestyle. If we move the needle on donor retention, then the rest of our culture of philanthropy changes. And revenue changes along with it, and this makes fundraisers happy. 
What is our role in this? Our role is to radically transform the way we perform donor relations. It's no longer ok to focus our efforts at the top of the pyramid, regardless of the fact that over 80% of our revenue comes from the top. If we don't split our time equally, yup 50/50, then those entry level donors will NEVER grow to be major donors if they don't make a second gift. So it's our job, our pleasure,  to examine their behavior and what it tells us. Look at the following behaviors and make sure you have a corresponding donor relations touch for each one:
  • First Time Donors
  • Loyal Donors of more than 5 years
  • Donors who upgrade their gift by 25% or more
  • Donors who have lapsed and then returned
  • Monthly or sustaining donors who make more than 4 gifts a year
  • Online only/digital donors
There are samples of many of these on my site, I'd love to see yours. What I'd also like to see disappear is charts of what we do for donors based on their amount, that can be a factor later, after we've looked at their behavior FIRST. We need to show them we notice them and that they are unique and they will come back, and so will their gifts...

Time for a radical shift in the way we behave, and the donors will follow.
What are your thoughts?
Cheers,

Lynne

Thursday, January 15, 2015

T-Rexes vs. Kangaroos

One of the challenges I often see in our organizations is the diversity of our fundraising workforce. Nope I'm not talking about the fact that we as an industry lack ethnic and socioeconomic diversity in spades, I'm talking about the never ending struggle between two groups. 

Now you're going to have to have a good sense of humor to make it through this blog and a vivid imagination...

Picture this if you will:



These are two opposing forces at work in our fundraising profession. 
Disclaimer: Help me out here by not focusing on the fact that these can be sweeping generalizations and are not true of everyone.

We have the T-Rexes,  wonderful people who have worked in our organizations for a long time (hence the pre-historic bend) and who are generally adverse to change. When a new idea comes, they use their ferocious growl and their short arms to try and bat new ideas down.

Then you have the kangaroos, (note: not the job hoppers) but they've only been at the organization for a while, have worked at other non-profits and come bouncing in with a pouch full of new ideas and limitless energy. They annoy the heck outta the T-Rexes who have seen them bounce in and out and around and the T-Rexes are still there, regardless. 

Have you ever seen a kangaroo fight? They're good at it! And, wow at the persistence (this is a google and youtube moment here) But everyone is so scared of the T-Rex that they won't even attempt it. And this my friends is one of the reasons why our organizations cannot be innovative.

How do we soothe the fears of the T-Rexes and allow the kangaroos to adapt to the culture of the organization without each of them wishing the other extinct. How do we ensure that our culture doesn't run the kangaroo off? (Remember the average tenure of a front line fundraiser is 16 months right now). How do we get each of them to extend their short little arms for an HR appropriate embrace?

The answer is that we must allow each person to understand that whether they hop around the office or stomp around the office, the relationship that matters the most is the one we have with our donors. They are the center of our universe, whether it be a pre-historic swamp, or a grassland down unda.

If we keep our mission and the donor at the center, then the length and effectiveness of our arms matters not. Our eons long divide shortens and we focus on what truly matters, the wonderful experience of philanthropy. Because for all the differences between a T-Rex and a kangaroo, they share a world view that philanthropy matters. And when we point out that shared commonality, the differences begin to fade...

Do you know a T-Rex? A Kangaroo? How do these forces come into play at your organization?
I would love to hear your thoughts.

Cheers,
Lynne


Thursday, January 8, 2015

Everyone Must Believe

“The moment you doubt whether you can fly, you cease for ever to be able to do it.”
― J.M. Barrie,
Peter Pan

I'm here in Anaheim California and I thought that this quote would be a great beginning to a post about how donor relations truly works best in an organization. I think it is essential, inextricable, vital that the donor focus start at the top. Not at the top of the donor pyramid, but at the top of the leadership pyramid of your organization. In order to revolutionize your organization's relationship with donors, the top must believe, and then you can fly. 

I often come into organizations where someone along the great food chain has bought into the idea of donor relations and realizes the success they can have by forming proper donor relationships and putting donors at the center of what they do. The crucial point of the visit usually occurs when I meet the person in charge of the organization and ask their opinion on what it would be like to have ideal donor relations. If their eyes twinkle and the words, "it's not just the right thing to do, it's a privilege" come flowing freely, then I know we can go far. If they hesitate and hem and haw about process and procedure and the importance of "getting dollars in the door" then I know we have a bumpy road to travel. 

You see,  the mindset must be part of a culture. And more than a culture of philanthropy, a wonderful organization must have what I call an "attitude of gratitude". And folks, that starts at the top. Leaders who are willing to throw themselves into thanking donors, even those who haven't given millions, inspire me. And what they get out of it is multiplied, they see first hand that the simple act of gratitude can change their outlook, inspire good will and give them a glimpse into a philanthropist's heart. I am thrilled to say that these leaders far outnumber those who say, "I'll hire someone to do that touchy feely stuff."

So what's your goal in 2015? Maybe one of them should be to assess the culture of gratitude at your organization. Find out if people begrudgingly write thank you notes or if it's something they enjoy. It will tell you a great deal about where you're headed and how. I look to partner with people who "get it" and understand that gratitude is one of the best parts of our job. People often ask me how to know if someone will be a good fit for donor relations if they have no prior experience. I tell them easily, if the person has gratitude in their heart and is quick to express it, that's someone I want talking to donors. That's someone who believes. 

Who believes at your organization? How do they allow you to fly? I look forward to hearing from you on how you assess the culture where you are. Happy new year and here's to a great 2015 in flight!

Cheers,
Lynne 

Wednesday, December 17, 2014

Naughty and Nice List

I've never been one to hold my tongue and at this time of Hannukah, Christmas and other holidays, I can't make an exception here. I've recently received some communications that make my heart sing and others that truly deserve a lump of coal. Many of you always ask me for examples of nonprofits that are nailing donor relations, and I love exposing others who are far from best practice. So here you go, ho ho ho! My Naughty and Nice list this 2014 season! I'll be back blogging after the holidays and a much needed break, until then may your season be merry and bright.

Sugarplums and Delights Go to:

Charity: Water for this amazing email about why they give and also these social media posts telling donor stories click on the image to lead you to the magic:

https://medium.com/@charitywater/why-we-give-9274dfd52bb1




Candy Canes as well to Kalamazoo College, I received a great email from them with an impact report that was simply phenomenal, check it out:

http://www.kzoo.edu/giving/kcf/impact/

 Then, it links to an amazing piece called "The Journey of a Gift" WOW. Absolutely Phenomenal. I will be continuing my giving to Kalamazoo. Kudos and Light to them!



Finally on my Nice list is Whitworth University, who I've been humbled enough to work with for the past two years. Their donor relations and fundraising program is inspired and gratitude centered. From their "Gratituesdays" on Social Media to the President and his Cabinet spending part of their retreat calling donors to say thank you to the amazing message below, they're doing it right folks. Not just good, but great and inspired! Their attitude of gratitude is infectious and positively radient!


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UST6-cEMptU&feature=youtu.be


My Naughty List and Lumps of Coal to the Following:

St. Jude's Children's Hospital: For offering a Christmas ornament for a monthly gift. We all know that tchotckes decrease giving, also, what if I'm not Christian? Do I have this from my menorah? Come on, we can do better, can't we? Stale, Chewy year old candy canes to them for this





Heifer International: for the worst and most solicitations humanly possible:
I gave a gift to them online as a part of #GivingTuesday, as a result since December 2nd, I have received more than 11 solicitations. 11 solicitations and one thank you email that also had an ask in it- THIS IS NO GOOD FOLKS! In addition, this email sent me over the edge: The subject line was the word "done"


Wait, Jinny, this email is completely about YOU and not ME. It's selfish and horrible and just all out wrong. I don't think I've ever been so insulted by an email before. I think Tom Ahern would be boiling and the number of times that Jinny talks about herself and shames me for not having finished my holiday shopping yet. SIGH. This is all about shopping and not about their mission, about the impact of my gift or anything relevant to me. Kudos to you Heifer International for having the ABSOLUTE worst, most GRINCH-LIKE solicitation ever. Two lumps of coal for you (or maybe it should be bunny poop).

 
So what do you think?
I hope you all have seen something this holiday season that has inspired you, I'm so happy to report that my list of additional nice organizations includes many many more. But the ones that are naughty are so close to Veruca Salt it's not funny anymore. Send me your holiday greetings, appeals and let's discuss how and why these things happen, nominate an organization below and send me a sample of their work and let's keep the discussion moving. 
Cheers,
Lynne