Thursday, March 12, 2015

Lack of Diversity in the Fundraising Profession

Ok, so this blog is probably going to get me into some trouble. But hey, when have I ever shied away from being controversial? With all that has been happening now across America and with all that I have seen and experienced, I wouldn't be true to myself if I didn't write this post. 

As I travel all across this land, and sometimes even north of the border, I am constantly disappointed by the lack of diversity in the room. I'm not just talking ethnic diversity, I'm also talking religious, sexual orientation and socioeconomic diversity. We are not doing a great job as leaders representing our constituencies. The faces are mostly white, mostly upper middle class and the people we are raising funds for are certainly not. And don't get me started on what our volunteer boards look like. In the field of donor relations it's even worse. We're 90 percent white females. We represent institutions of higher learning, nonprofits that help change the state of poverty, hospitals who cure illnesses and yet I believe we have a problem within. One would think that higher education would be a wonderful place to promote diversity and inclusion, but when looking further, if we consistently refuse to change our own processes and avoid progress in our methodologies to fund raise how can we expect to change the recruitment of diverse populations of professionals?

We don't actively recruit and mentor people who don't even know that fundraising is a career possibility. There is, in fact an active glass ceiling in fundraising for some as well. We need to reach out to people and educate then on what a fabulous career this is and how they can become involved. That means reaching out to people who are not currently connected with or employed by a nonprofit organization, but who are seeking to enter the profession or change careers. This also means being comfortable with having uncomfortable discussions on issues surrounding race, religion and socioeconomic status. 

Embracing diversity means having a genuine respect for differing perspectives, so that solutions encompass all diverse views and needs. Diversity increases the wealth of knowledge and ideas available, as long as they all look for creative and mutually satisfactory solutions. We must be committed to inclusion ourselves and make our profession attractive to those who have not previously been exposed to it. It takes commitment to move the needle. We must be concerned with how to keep diversity/inclusion at the forefront of people’s consciousness, and not be seen in a negative light. This requires systematic change, embedded in everything we do.

I have seen many examples of language or communications where if a diverse eye were directed toward the content, it would have been significantly altered. Here's one example of missing the mark when it comes to diversity and sensitivity, and I can find many others.

For those of you reading this and feeling uncomfortable, good, mission accomplished. For those of you nodding heads and actively sharing this post with others, what's the next step? First awareness of the problem, then action and activity. I think many of us are aware of the problem, but have not yet taken concerted action. I approach this subject knowing it will raise eyebrows with some and elicit eyerolls from others. I'm determined to share my vocation with others, it's a wonderful profession. I would love to hear your comments below. at the very least I hope this has jogged your thoughts, compelled you to share this post and at least think about possible long term solutions. Thanks for listening.
Cheers,
Lynne

Wednesday, March 4, 2015

Is it 1952 or 2015?

Kudos to my friend Allison who sent me the article that spurred this post- 
You can read the article here, it's quite hilarious.

When is the last time you updated your addressing and salutation standards for your organization?
Wait, do you even have addressing and salutation standards at your organization?
If you don't it's one of the fundamentals of a good donor relations program that can help your entire institution. I would be a hypocrite if I talked all about it and didn't have one of my own so you can find an examples of one of the ones I use here.  

The author has a point, not just for same sex couples, but for all kinds of households. Remember that now, we also have many households that include multiple generations. Take a look at your mailings, your address fields on giving forms and other opportunities to make an error. 

I have to tell you, as a divorcee, I also see some things that set me back on my heels. I often see on forms, "please indicate the name of your spouse so we can share credit with them" and this is a mandatory field on a giving form. So I happily type Brad Pitt or Idris Elba and keep on clicking... wait you mean if I type it that doesn't make it true? If you're going to demand silly information, I'm not going to live in reality either. Also why a spouse? Can you call it a spouse or partner? Why not just ask me if there is someone I would like to share credit with? What if I want to share credit with someone I don't live with? 

Also, say someone does happen to "have a conscious uncoupling" when someone uncouples them in your database, are you ensuring that one of their addresses is also updated? I mean, in reality, someone gets to keep the house. Someone also needs a new address, are you running a clean up report to ensure you try to avoid a possibly embarrassing blunder?

We have to be conscientious of our constituents and their needs, we must adapt our rigid policies and procedures to the inescapable human truth, people desire the need to be recognized for who they are, not for what box they check. We need to recognize that as a population changes or trends emerge we need to be on the forefront, not 20 years behind... something to think about.

What are your thoughts? How do you adapt to the changing landscape? Would you like to share a link to your policies? I look forward to hearing from you.

Cheers,
Lynne

Thursday, February 26, 2015

The Blank Page

Many times, the topic for this blog comes from the strangest places. It could be a long plane ride, or something I've read in the news lately or just from something that frustrates me. But each and every one starts with a blank page. When I was working on my first Master's degree I learned a lot about the "tabula rasa" or blank slate. 

And you know what? That's how we start with our donors. We have a blank slate, a opportunity to build an amazing relationship with them and to ensure that what we write has power and meaning to them. At times the blank page can become overwhelming. I always like to start when I'm writing for donors by typing the theme words or goals of what I'm trying to accomplish with my writing at the top of the page. It makes the page less lonely and keeps me focused on my theme and the important part. I also write at the top of the page the following, "It's not about you, it's about the donor." That really helps me keep things in perspective.

If all else fails and I'm really in a rut, I might try taking someone else's sample, that's why I started the writing swaps on my website years ago, and adapt it to my needs. I find that at times that blank slate can be completely intimidating and will overwhelm you. How do we convey such profound gratitude to others while making our message clear? How do we not get lost in jargon and telling someone all about us? We keep focused, we drive the message home that the donor is the hero and we are humbled by their generosity.

Also I like to model my writing from others who inspire me. I'm a voracious reader and find that the more I read, the better writer I become. I'm not flowery or poetic, I'm more a Hemingway kinda girl. Some people say my emails resemble tweets they're so short. I call them efficient. With our donors, remember that every second to them is precious and we need to respect that. Why tell them in two pages what two good paragraphs could have done? As you think about how we communicate and write for our donors what are the things you take into account? What are the behaviors that others have in their writing that you would like to imitate or that drive you bonkers? 

"If I had more time, I would have written a shorter letter." - Blaise Pascal

Thursday, February 19, 2015

How Does Your Organization Stand Out to Donors?

According to multiple studies, those in our populations who are philanthropic do so with multiple organizations. Most people who give their wealth and resources do not do so with just one organization. This creates a competitive charitable environment. So what are you doing to allow your organization to stand out in the minds and hearts of these donors? How are you able to obtain a larger share of their philanthropic giving? What follows are just some of my tips to help you focus your efforts.

Demonstrate impact - One of the things that sets great organizations apart from good organizations is their consistent ability to show their donors where their money was spent and how it was spent and the impact of that investment on the organization. Might I say here that the other caveat is that these organizations make the donor the hero, and don't glamorize just the organization and leave the donor in the dust. It's not about you.

Don't waste their time- Most philanthropic people, heck, all people are busy. With work and life and family and activities and blizzards. Who has time to read a 4 page newsletter? Not the folks you're trying to reach. Remember the #1 way to access information about your organization is through the internet and the vast majority of information on the internet is accessed through mobile devices. If the donor has to scroll through more than three screens, you've lost them. Period. Average attention span of an adult is 7 seconds, a goldfish, 8 seconds. Need I say more?


Don't overwhelm with tons of info about you- Because this isn't about YOU. It's one thing to inform and educate, it's a totally different thing to shove your prefabricated mission and vision down people's throats. Give information in digestible forms. Become an expert at storytelling. If you tell a good story, they'll remember the facts. Use infographics and creative ways to express your data.

Be clever- If everyone else does it, why are you a lemming? Stand out and embrace creativity. Don't think outside the box, the box doesn't exist. Seriously if I receive one more solicitation that is 2 or more pages front and back in a windowed #10 envelope... grrr. What's wrong with taking a risk? Time to break free from the old standard and reinvent yourself. You'll attract new donors and impress the ones you already have.

Involve others to help you- I'm talking board members and volunteers here people. At MINIMUM your board has to have 100% participation in giving. With NO exceptions. If they don't give, why should I? If they don't like fundraising, great, have them thank donors instead. Everyone can have a role in helping your organization fundraise, it's not all about the ask. Peer to peer is the best. I've given to probably 40-50 organizations last year. Do you know how many phone calls or thank yous from board or volunteers I've received? ZERO. sigh.


What are your thoughts? How do you stand out from the crowd?
Cheers,
Lynne

Wednesday, February 11, 2015

And If Everyone Else Jumps off a Cliff?

I enjoy receiving emails from folks all over the world asking for advice. I do my best to answer them within 24 hours and ensure I give real life advice from my experiences and based on best and next practices. 

Here is an example of an email that suggests to me that sometimes we have a larger problem facing us. "My supervisor said that Nonprofit X is doing (insert horrible practice here) and that we should do it too". Le Sigh. Just because another organization does it or that it worked in one instance doesn't mean it's best practice or even a legal practice. 

Here are some of the examples I've read lately that make my stomach flip:
- putting a business reply envelope in with the receipt
- withholding scholarship money from a student because they didn't write a note to a donor
- giving an acrylic tchotcke/paperweight to a donor with their name inscribed on it for their deferred gift
- putting the link to the giving website on every single communication
- ignoring donor retention numbers and instead only focusing on alumni participation

Like your mother said growing up, just because Jimmy jumps off a cliff, are you going to do it too? I think that there are a few horrible reasons to do something in the nonprofit sector and here are my "hit list":
- We've always done it that way
- "So and So" does this
- One of our donors says they like it
- XX Vendor says it works for them at XX organization

How are you challenging assumptions? Are you using guiding principals to help you make decisions? When something doesn't "feel right" are you questioning it? I have to tell you that if you let data drive your efforts, some of these pitfalls are easy to avoid. Also your general counsel and others can help you stay out of a danger zone as well. We all want to do better for our organizations. If we didn't we wouldn't be in this industry. We care, about our mission, about our supporters, about our work. So why do we succumb to these pressures? Because we aren't always provided with wonderful alternatives. We have to be advocates for our donors and supporters. Remember, if it doesn't benefit the donor, we shouldn't be doing it.

Help me help you fight the good fight and question authority. It's perfectly acceptable to reason something out and use empirical evidence rather than anecdotal evidence. And if you need help, I'm only an email away.

I would love to hear your thoughts on the issue. 
Cheers,
Lynne

Wednesday, February 4, 2015

The ROI of Donor Relations

Having the opportunity to help organizations change their relationships with donors is a phenomenal privilege. Combine that with helping them realize a boost to their bottom line through donor relations and I'm in hog heaven!

Donor relations has a tangible return on investment, every time, in every way. And we can prove it. Throughout my travels I meet people who say to me, "If only you knew the thrill of being a fundraiser." After I give them a major side eye, and note their nametag for future reference, I tell them that not only have I been a fundraiser, I AM a fundraiser. Donor relations makes money for an organization, more importantly, it keeps money from leaving.

Here are some recent examples of ROI through donor relations: One of my clients just redesigned their endowment reports and sent them out with a survey asking donors how they did. Not only did they receive wonderful feedback on their process and new reports, they also received over $25,000 in unsolicited gifts in those surveys. Same thing for another client. They went through the same arduous process of revamping endowed fund stewardship, and while it was at times painful and frustrating, no one is mad at the over $75,000 they received unsolicited in the mail with their feedback surveys. That's $100,000 none of us would turn down if it showed up in our bank accounts.

Think about it in another way. If donor relations does their job well and becomes retention experts, then we can prove the ROI of retention on our first time donors and donors over time. My friends at the Agitator talk about donor retention all the time, and their facts are dead on. So how do we prove the ROI of donor relations? We MUST track it. We need to look at retention rates, donors who upgrade, donors who make unsolicited gifts, and we need to say, wow... look at all of the money coming in as a result of making the donation process a joyful one. Acquisition of new donors is easy to track, it's also 7 times more expensive to obtain a new donor than it is to keep the one you have. What would a decrease of 10% in the acquisition budget and moving it to donor relations mean in terms of ROI? I can tell you , it means a great deal. 

Why do these numbers matter? Because leadership needs and wants them. In order to advocate for more resources, donor relations has to show a tangible ROI of every effort we do, both large and small. When I quantify the impact of donor relations on an organization, heads begin to swivel, fundraisers begin to take notice and the importance of donor relations rises. After all, it's very hard to ask for money from a donor who left your organization after their first donation...

What are your thoughts? How do you prove ROI of donor relations at your organization?
Cheers,
Lynne


Wednesday, January 28, 2015

Words Matter, Especially to Your Donors

I hope everyone is well and for those of you in New England, safe and sound. 

Recently, I received two communications that are so stunningly perverse I had to bring them to you. As you know, I love my profession, I love fundraising and non profits, but every once in a while, I just have to throw up my hands and scream.

I received an email the other day, here's the first line:
Seriously folks? That is supposed to inspire me? Should I feel gratitude and well thanked? Nope, I actually feel like the PHA doesn't know me at all. The great irony, is that I didn't even make a gift to their "year end appeal", I gave as a result of Giving Tuesday, not as a result of their solicitations. I would laugh, but instead I'm sad. My good friend Mark, who writes on leadership and training for fundraisers here, said this on my Facebook: "Reminds me of story of the disappointed president when he found out an alumnus had given $40 million to a research institute instead of the $20 million gift he had solicited from the same donor for his alma mater. Said the donor: "You asked me to help finish your campaign. They asked me to help cure cancer and save lives."

I was so hoping this was an anomaly, but sadly, I know it's not. Two days later, I received this in the mail from an organization I've never supported before and who clearly bought my contact information from one I have. Le Sigh. 




"My annual fund enclosed" is so inspiring. And having a president of a national organization address me as "friend" in a bad hand written mocking font moves my philanthropic heart more than you know. 

But here's the kicker- I was told to detach the next bit of the mailing and place it in my wallet with pride...

 Speechless. I'll put it right next to my health insurance? Or my Delta Sky Miles Card?

Yes, fundraising is a business, but we need to leave our business jargon out of it and instead tell our story and inspire our donors with that story. Folks, it's not about us, it's about them. The more we make the donor the hero, the better we all are. Words matter. Choose them carefully and let them inspire those that inspire us so much to continue our craft. Not only can we do better we must do better. Because it matters, not just to us, but to them and the future of our causes.

What are your thoughts? Am I being to harsh or are these examples as tragic as I believe? How do you combat jargon and junk to your donors? 
Have any great examples? Share them here:

Cheers,
Lynne